Can AI-Written Emails Really Increase Open Rates?

AI Written Emails are becoming a popular choice for busy marketers.
Email campaigns take time, and writing subject lines again and again can feel exhausting.

That’s why many teams turn to AI to speed up email writing and improve open rates. But do AI-written emails actually work in real inboxes? Let’s look at the reality based on testing, not hype.

Why Marketers Are Using AI Written Emails

Email inboxes are crowded. Standing out is hard.

Marketers use AI for emails because it promises:

• Faster email writing
• Better subject lines
• Data-based suggestions
• Less creative fatigue

On paper, it sounds perfect.

ALSO READ

Why Most Social Media Caption AI Tools Fail to Drive Engagement

How We Tested AI Written Emails

To avoid theory, we tested AI emails in real campaigns.

Testing setup:

• Same audience size
• Same sending time
• Same email offer
• One version written by AI
• One version edited by a human

The only change was the email copy.

Do AI Written Emails Improve Open Rates?

The short answer: sometimes.

In many cases, AI helped improve open rates slightly. But results were not consistent across all campaigns.

What mattered most was how AI was used, not just using it.

Where AI Written Emails Perform Well

1. Subject Line Ideas

AI is strong at generating multiple subject lines quickly.

It helps with:

• Variations for A/B testing
• Clear wording
• Removing guesswork

This alone can improve open rate testing speed.

2. Clarity Over Creativity

AI-written copy is usually:

• Clear
• Short
• Easy to understand

For informational emails, this works well.

Where AI Written Emails Fall Short

1. Lack of Emotional Connection

AI emails often feel correct but cold.

They miss:

• Curiosity
• Urgency
• Personal tone

Subscribers notice this quickly.

2. Generic Language

Without custom prompts, AI produces safe phrases.

This leads to:

• Predictable subject lines
• Low curiosity
• Average performance

Email opens depend heavily on feeling, not just logic.

Real Campaign Result Example

In one campaign test:

• AI-only email: moderate open rate
• Human-written email: slightly higher
• AI + human-edited email: best result

The winning version combined speed with human judgment.

Common Mistakes When Using AI for Email Writing

Many marketers expect too much from AI.

Mistakes to avoid:

• Sending AI emails without editing
• Using the same prompt every time
• Ignoring brand voice
• Chasing automation over connection

These mistakes reduce trust and engagement.

How to Use AI Written Emails the Right Way

Here’s what worked best in testing:

1. Use AI to draft subject lines
2. Edit tone manually
3. Add personalization
4. Test small changes
5. Track results, not assumptions

AI should support decisions, not replace them.

AI Emails vs Human Emails (Quick Comparison)

Factor	AI Only	Human + AI
Speed	Fast	Moderate
Emotion	Low	High
Consistency	High	Balanced
Open Rates	Mixed	Better

The hybrid approach wins most of the time.

Are AI Written Emails Worth Using?

Yes — with realistic expectations.

They are worth using if you:

• Run frequent campaigns
• Test subject lines often
• Want faster drafts

They are not ideal if you:

• Skip human review
• Depend on automation alone
• Ignore audience behavior

Used wisely, AI-generated emails can support better email performance.

ALSO READ

AI Advertising Tools Tested: Which One Actually Converts Better Ads?

Conclusion

AI can help emails get opened, but it is not a magic switch.

The biggest gains came when marketers used AI for speed and humans for judgment. When combined correctly, AI Written Emails can increase efficiency without harming trust.

The key is balance, not blind automation.

FAQs